National Research Centre

Medical Research Ethics Committee

MREC Reviewer Comment

Protocol Title

Use of Untargeted Metabolomics to predict fertility in Egyptian buffalo.

Completely satisfied and informative data

Needs Explanation

Comments to the applicant

Dr. Siham Soliman    Affiliation: NRC …. Needs more information

- Co-researcher Dr. Sharif Mohamed Afifi, and his email is: Naglaaammar@yahoo.com      Please revise the e-mail address

- The Author mentioned that the proposal was not reviewed by a specialized scientific committee, while it was revised technically by the department

- The Author mentioned that the ages of studied Buffalos were from 4-7 years and their weight ranged from 400-5500 kilos, and this is impossible.

- I think this research was completed because the work was from January to April, 2023 and this is against the regulations of the ethics committee from the beginning of this year.

- The Author mentioned in the experiment procedures that the ages of the studied Buffalos were from 4-7 years, and in another place she mentioned that the ages were 3-5 years.

- The Author did not mention the size of the blood sample, but mentioned that she will take them in a 1.5 mm Eppendorf tube? In another place, she mentioned that she will take 10 ml of blood sample/animal.

- She stated that there was no pain even though she took blood from the jugular vein.

Comment to the Committee

Dr. Siham Soliman    Affiliation: NRC …. Needs more information

- Co-researcher Dr. Sharif Mohamed Afifi, and his email is: Naglaaammar@yahoo.com      Please revise the e-mail address

- The Author mentioned that the proposal was not reviewed by a specialized scientific committee, while it was revised technically by the department

- The Author mentioned that the ages of studied Buffalos were from 4-7 years and their weight ranged from 400-5500 kilos, and this is impossible.

- I think this research was completed because the work was from January to April, 2023 and this is against the regulations of the ethics committee from the beginning of this year.

- The Author mentioned in the experiment procedures that the ages of the studied Buffalos were from 4-7 years, and in another place she mentioned that the ages were 3-5 years.

- The Author did not mention the size of the blood sample, but mentioned that she will take them in a 1.5 mm Eppendorf tube? In another place, she mentioned that she will take 10 ml of blood sample/animal.

- She stated that there was no pain even though she took blood from the jugular vein.

Informed consent form:

N/A

Login

Email Address *
Enter your username or email address
password *
Enter your password

Reset Password

User login/email

Still not a member? Register