National Research Centre

Medical Research Ethics Committee

MREC Reviewer Comment

Protocol Title

Nutritional Value, Antioxidant Activity And Sensory Evaluation Of Edible Mushroom (Pleurotus Ostreatus) As A Supplementation To Create Healthier Meat Products

Completely satisfied and informative data

Needs Explanation

Comments to the applicant

* Title in Arabic:

-تعديل الكتابة الملخبطة

-استبدال كتابة الاسم العلمى باللغة العربية ( بليوروتس اوستراتيوس)

* Areas of expertise:

- Written name of the Faculty. Must be written The field of specialization and expertise.

- Role/tasks in the research: Written objective of the study. Must be written role and tasks in this research.

* Research site name: Written name of the authors. Correct it.

* Study Type: Written other, without writing the type (field) of study.

* Duration of the study: Written 3 months, while Written in Gantt-charts 6 months. Correct it.

* Reviewing by the Scientific Committee: Written No.

* 1Co-Investigator: Written other, without writing the Job title.

* Subject Area: Written Others: Sensory Evaluation. Need to correct it to Nutritional evaluation.

* Background:

- Need support by writing about the benefits of mushrooms. And the burger. Provided with references.

- It contains one reference and is not found in the reference list.

* Procedure in Details:

- Writing in the past tense (were washed - were crushed - were mixed - were evaluated - was carried out). It must be in the future tense.

- Didn't explain several main important subjects:

1. Ethanol extract preparation.

2, Nutritional evaluation components.

3. Antioxidant activity (components and methodology).

4. Sensory evaluation (components and methodology).

* Safety: Did not anything. Although, the research includes laboratory work and sensory evaluation for burger by 10 panellists.

* List of References:

- It contains only 4 references, most of it about effect of light conditions on the content of selected active ingredients. Must be added References about using and adding mushrooms to burgers.

Comment to the Committee

Reviewing by the Scientific Committee: Written No ???

Informed consent form:

Accepted

Login

Email Address *
Enter your username or email address
password *
Enter your password

Reset Password

User login/email

Still not a member? Register